How is the Incom shipyard still in business?
Following on from this question, what is the in-universe explanation that Incom, the sole manufacturer of X-Wings, is permitted by the Empire to remain in business? From the Empire's POV the rebels are terrorists and it would be easy to locate and shut down the shipyard making their very distinctive fighters.
star-wars
add a comment |
Following on from this question, what is the in-universe explanation that Incom, the sole manufacturer of X-Wings, is permitted by the Empire to remain in business? From the Empire's POV the rebels are terrorists and it would be easy to locate and shut down the shipyard making their very distinctive fighters.
star-wars
2
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
2
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
1
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
1
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago
add a comment |
Following on from this question, what is the in-universe explanation that Incom, the sole manufacturer of X-Wings, is permitted by the Empire to remain in business? From the Empire's POV the rebels are terrorists and it would be easy to locate and shut down the shipyard making their very distinctive fighters.
star-wars
Following on from this question, what is the in-universe explanation that Incom, the sole manufacturer of X-Wings, is permitted by the Empire to remain in business? From the Empire's POV the rebels are terrorists and it would be easy to locate and shut down the shipyard making their very distinctive fighters.
star-wars
star-wars
asked 10 hours ago
GaiusGaius
750616
750616
2
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
2
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
1
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
1
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago
add a comment |
2
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
2
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
1
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
1
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago
2
2
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
2
2
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
1
1
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
1
1
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
1
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
The implication is that X-Wings were produced commercially. The Rebels were probably only a minor customer, but their successful use at the Battle of Yavin meant that they became synonymous with the Rebellion.
Ciena bit her lower lip as she studied her readings. “I read five
ships, probably starfighters. So far I can’t ID ship models, but I’d
guess we’re looking at X-wings or Y-wings.” While a handful of those
starfighters remained in civilian hands, by now X-wings and Y-wings
were used almost solely by the Rebel Alliance. Piett’s intel had been
correct; the TIE patrol would move into attack mode at any moment.
Star Wars: Lost Stars
When asked how the Rebellion had managed to lay their hands on them, Matt Martin, Lucasfilm Exec (and member of the Lucasfilm Story Group) indicated that they were, at one point, available to purchase by planetary governments.
Q. I recall that the Lost Stars novel mentioned that x-wings were available to the public before being solely affiliated with the rebellion. Were they civilian craft at some point? I kinda confused on that part...
MM: I'm not sure if I'd go as far as to say there was a civilian version. They were likely available to local planetary defense fleets, militias, etc.
Q. So it basically went from an Imperial reject craft, to a local defense ship for militias, and the Rebels decide to take em in. No hijacking required. Got it, thx.
MM: Something like that. I’m sure the full history of the X-wing can’t be explained in a tweet.
Via Twitter
add a comment |
This is based on Legends canon information, but as there are no canon level tags added to this question it is relavent.
The 1980s produced West End Games RPG stated that Incom was taken under control of the Galatic Empire, however many of its staff particularly the X-Wing design team were sympathetic to the Alliance and smuggled the X-Wing designs and Prototypes to the Alliance.
X-Wings were manufactured in hidden Alliance facilities in places that were not fully under Imperial control.
The Empire rounded up the Incom staff and placed them into transports to be taken to a prison planet. The Alliance intercepted these freeing the Incom personnel.
Later after the fall of the Empire as David Jonston notes in his answer they formed a new Incom producing fighters for the New Republic.
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
add a comment |
Star Wars Rogue One The Ultimate Visual Guide says Incom was in fact taken over by the Empire to cut them off as a source of weapons for the Rebels. However they apparently went back into the X-Wing business after they were taken away from the Empire by the Rebellion. Wookiepedia says they were producing updated X-Wings for the New Republic under the name Incom-FreiTech which presumably reflects a merger.
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f206476%2fhow-is-the-incom-shipyard-still-in-business%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The implication is that X-Wings were produced commercially. The Rebels were probably only a minor customer, but their successful use at the Battle of Yavin meant that they became synonymous with the Rebellion.
Ciena bit her lower lip as she studied her readings. “I read five
ships, probably starfighters. So far I can’t ID ship models, but I’d
guess we’re looking at X-wings or Y-wings.” While a handful of those
starfighters remained in civilian hands, by now X-wings and Y-wings
were used almost solely by the Rebel Alliance. Piett’s intel had been
correct; the TIE patrol would move into attack mode at any moment.
Star Wars: Lost Stars
When asked how the Rebellion had managed to lay their hands on them, Matt Martin, Lucasfilm Exec (and member of the Lucasfilm Story Group) indicated that they were, at one point, available to purchase by planetary governments.
Q. I recall that the Lost Stars novel mentioned that x-wings were available to the public before being solely affiliated with the rebellion. Were they civilian craft at some point? I kinda confused on that part...
MM: I'm not sure if I'd go as far as to say there was a civilian version. They were likely available to local planetary defense fleets, militias, etc.
Q. So it basically went from an Imperial reject craft, to a local defense ship for militias, and the Rebels decide to take em in. No hijacking required. Got it, thx.
MM: Something like that. I’m sure the full history of the X-wing can’t be explained in a tweet.
Via Twitter
add a comment |
The implication is that X-Wings were produced commercially. The Rebels were probably only a minor customer, but their successful use at the Battle of Yavin meant that they became synonymous with the Rebellion.
Ciena bit her lower lip as she studied her readings. “I read five
ships, probably starfighters. So far I can’t ID ship models, but I’d
guess we’re looking at X-wings or Y-wings.” While a handful of those
starfighters remained in civilian hands, by now X-wings and Y-wings
were used almost solely by the Rebel Alliance. Piett’s intel had been
correct; the TIE patrol would move into attack mode at any moment.
Star Wars: Lost Stars
When asked how the Rebellion had managed to lay their hands on them, Matt Martin, Lucasfilm Exec (and member of the Lucasfilm Story Group) indicated that they were, at one point, available to purchase by planetary governments.
Q. I recall that the Lost Stars novel mentioned that x-wings were available to the public before being solely affiliated with the rebellion. Were they civilian craft at some point? I kinda confused on that part...
MM: I'm not sure if I'd go as far as to say there was a civilian version. They were likely available to local planetary defense fleets, militias, etc.
Q. So it basically went from an Imperial reject craft, to a local defense ship for militias, and the Rebels decide to take em in. No hijacking required. Got it, thx.
MM: Something like that. I’m sure the full history of the X-wing can’t be explained in a tweet.
Via Twitter
add a comment |
The implication is that X-Wings were produced commercially. The Rebels were probably only a minor customer, but their successful use at the Battle of Yavin meant that they became synonymous with the Rebellion.
Ciena bit her lower lip as she studied her readings. “I read five
ships, probably starfighters. So far I can’t ID ship models, but I’d
guess we’re looking at X-wings or Y-wings.” While a handful of those
starfighters remained in civilian hands, by now X-wings and Y-wings
were used almost solely by the Rebel Alliance. Piett’s intel had been
correct; the TIE patrol would move into attack mode at any moment.
Star Wars: Lost Stars
When asked how the Rebellion had managed to lay their hands on them, Matt Martin, Lucasfilm Exec (and member of the Lucasfilm Story Group) indicated that they were, at one point, available to purchase by planetary governments.
Q. I recall that the Lost Stars novel mentioned that x-wings were available to the public before being solely affiliated with the rebellion. Were they civilian craft at some point? I kinda confused on that part...
MM: I'm not sure if I'd go as far as to say there was a civilian version. They were likely available to local planetary defense fleets, militias, etc.
Q. So it basically went from an Imperial reject craft, to a local defense ship for militias, and the Rebels decide to take em in. No hijacking required. Got it, thx.
MM: Something like that. I’m sure the full history of the X-wing can’t be explained in a tweet.
Via Twitter
The implication is that X-Wings were produced commercially. The Rebels were probably only a minor customer, but their successful use at the Battle of Yavin meant that they became synonymous with the Rebellion.
Ciena bit her lower lip as she studied her readings. “I read five
ships, probably starfighters. So far I can’t ID ship models, but I’d
guess we’re looking at X-wings or Y-wings.” While a handful of those
starfighters remained in civilian hands, by now X-wings and Y-wings
were used almost solely by the Rebel Alliance. Piett’s intel had been
correct; the TIE patrol would move into attack mode at any moment.
Star Wars: Lost Stars
When asked how the Rebellion had managed to lay their hands on them, Matt Martin, Lucasfilm Exec (and member of the Lucasfilm Story Group) indicated that they were, at one point, available to purchase by planetary governments.
Q. I recall that the Lost Stars novel mentioned that x-wings were available to the public before being solely affiliated with the rebellion. Were they civilian craft at some point? I kinda confused on that part...
MM: I'm not sure if I'd go as far as to say there was a civilian version. They were likely available to local planetary defense fleets, militias, etc.
Q. So it basically went from an Imperial reject craft, to a local defense ship for militias, and the Rebels decide to take em in. No hijacking required. Got it, thx.
MM: Something like that. I’m sure the full history of the X-wing can’t be explained in a tweet.
Via Twitter
edited 8 hours ago
answered 8 hours ago
ValorumValorum
406k10929553179
406k10929553179
add a comment |
add a comment |
This is based on Legends canon information, but as there are no canon level tags added to this question it is relavent.
The 1980s produced West End Games RPG stated that Incom was taken under control of the Galatic Empire, however many of its staff particularly the X-Wing design team were sympathetic to the Alliance and smuggled the X-Wing designs and Prototypes to the Alliance.
X-Wings were manufactured in hidden Alliance facilities in places that were not fully under Imperial control.
The Empire rounded up the Incom staff and placed them into transports to be taken to a prison planet. The Alliance intercepted these freeing the Incom personnel.
Later after the fall of the Empire as David Jonston notes in his answer they formed a new Incom producing fighters for the New Republic.
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
add a comment |
This is based on Legends canon information, but as there are no canon level tags added to this question it is relavent.
The 1980s produced West End Games RPG stated that Incom was taken under control of the Galatic Empire, however many of its staff particularly the X-Wing design team were sympathetic to the Alliance and smuggled the X-Wing designs and Prototypes to the Alliance.
X-Wings were manufactured in hidden Alliance facilities in places that were not fully under Imperial control.
The Empire rounded up the Incom staff and placed them into transports to be taken to a prison planet. The Alliance intercepted these freeing the Incom personnel.
Later after the fall of the Empire as David Jonston notes in his answer they formed a new Incom producing fighters for the New Republic.
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
add a comment |
This is based on Legends canon information, but as there are no canon level tags added to this question it is relavent.
The 1980s produced West End Games RPG stated that Incom was taken under control of the Galatic Empire, however many of its staff particularly the X-Wing design team were sympathetic to the Alliance and smuggled the X-Wing designs and Prototypes to the Alliance.
X-Wings were manufactured in hidden Alliance facilities in places that were not fully under Imperial control.
The Empire rounded up the Incom staff and placed them into transports to be taken to a prison planet. The Alliance intercepted these freeing the Incom personnel.
Later after the fall of the Empire as David Jonston notes in his answer they formed a new Incom producing fighters for the New Republic.
This is based on Legends canon information, but as there are no canon level tags added to this question it is relavent.
The 1980s produced West End Games RPG stated that Incom was taken under control of the Galatic Empire, however many of its staff particularly the X-Wing design team were sympathetic to the Alliance and smuggled the X-Wing designs and Prototypes to the Alliance.
X-Wings were manufactured in hidden Alliance facilities in places that were not fully under Imperial control.
The Empire rounded up the Incom staff and placed them into transports to be taken to a prison planet. The Alliance intercepted these freeing the Incom personnel.
Later after the fall of the Empire as David Jonston notes in his answer they formed a new Incom producing fighters for the New Republic.
answered 7 hours ago
SarriesfanSarriesfan
2,0831617
2,0831617
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
add a comment |
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
Basically how it went in acquiring X-Wings in the Rebel storyline for the Empire at War game except for the more dramatic heist of the X-Wing prototypes, though that is of course also legends content.
– IG_42
3 hours ago
add a comment |
Star Wars Rogue One The Ultimate Visual Guide says Incom was in fact taken over by the Empire to cut them off as a source of weapons for the Rebels. However they apparently went back into the X-Wing business after they were taken away from the Empire by the Rebellion. Wookiepedia says they were producing updated X-Wings for the New Republic under the name Incom-FreiTech which presumably reflects a merger.
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
add a comment |
Star Wars Rogue One The Ultimate Visual Guide says Incom was in fact taken over by the Empire to cut them off as a source of weapons for the Rebels. However they apparently went back into the X-Wing business after they were taken away from the Empire by the Rebellion. Wookiepedia says they were producing updated X-Wings for the New Republic under the name Incom-FreiTech which presumably reflects a merger.
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
add a comment |
Star Wars Rogue One The Ultimate Visual Guide says Incom was in fact taken over by the Empire to cut them off as a source of weapons for the Rebels. However they apparently went back into the X-Wing business after they were taken away from the Empire by the Rebellion. Wookiepedia says they were producing updated X-Wings for the New Republic under the name Incom-FreiTech which presumably reflects a merger.
Star Wars Rogue One The Ultimate Visual Guide says Incom was in fact taken over by the Empire to cut them off as a source of weapons for the Rebels. However they apparently went back into the X-Wing business after they were taken away from the Empire by the Rebellion. Wookiepedia says they were producing updated X-Wings for the New Republic under the name Incom-FreiTech which presumably reflects a merger.
answered 9 hours ago
David JohnstonDavid Johnston
2,162917
2,162917
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
add a comment |
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
i.stack.imgur.com/anWoT.png - I'm not seeing where it says that were taken over to stem the flow of weaponry to the Rebellion.
– Valorum
7 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
I may be assuming too much, but I figured that the Empire taking control of Incom did accomplish that.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
That depends how much stock is in circulation.
– Valorum
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
Well clearly they still had what they still had. That's why they had X-Wings they used to defend their base in ANH. The difference is they wouldn't be able to get replacements from the source until and unless they took it back.
– David Johnston
6 hours ago
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f206476%2fhow-is-the-incom-shipyard-still-in-business%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
I could be wrong, but I would see the situation similar to Apple today. Terrorists use their products, but that is no Apple's fault. And for paperwork's sake it would be possible to purchase the crafts from an intermediary or type of ghost organization so that it does not appear to be the rebels purchasing them directly. If that is the case it would be difficult for the Empire to justify shutting down a massive business... like I said, I could be wrong, but outside of the galactic war there is still rule of law, commerce, and etc. all happening...
– Odin1806
10 hours ago
2
Could be something like we saw in Last Jedi... the weapons manufacturers are selling to both sides.
– Skooba
9 hours ago
1
@Skooba I can see the logic, but when one side the Tyrannical Government, I'd expect them to suppress sales to the other side. It's not like their two separate nation states your selling to under WTO rules.
– Jontia
9 hours ago
1
@Jontia Even so, the Empire still has to respect the rule of law (or give the appearance of it anyway). Observing due process gives the likes of Senator Organa plenty of room to halt the process or just tie it up in endless red tape.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
@Cadence I guess you could argue that in A New Hope the Empire was finally ready to ditch rule of law now that "fear will keep the local populations in line" and that the end came too swiftly afterwards to make it worth shutting down Incom. After all you have capital ship manufacturers to go after first.
– Jontia
7 hours ago