What happens to the Time Stone
(SPOILERS ahead - for the ones who didn't watch it yet)
In Avengers: Endgame, we learn that Thanos destroys the Infinity Stones. And then, the Avengers go back in time (perhaps to different realities) in order to gather Infinity Stones. Once they finish their work with these Infinity Stones, they are taken back to their respective realities. So, in the main timeline, where they bring back the dusted characters, there are no infinity stones.
But, consider the Time Stone. Doctor Strange and his sanctum swore to protect the Time Stone.
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame
New contributor
add a comment |
(SPOILERS ahead - for the ones who didn't watch it yet)
In Avengers: Endgame, we learn that Thanos destroys the Infinity Stones. And then, the Avengers go back in time (perhaps to different realities) in order to gather Infinity Stones. Once they finish their work with these Infinity Stones, they are taken back to their respective realities. So, in the main timeline, where they bring back the dusted characters, there are no infinity stones.
But, consider the Time Stone. Doctor Strange and his sanctum swore to protect the Time Stone.
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame
New contributor
add a comment |
(SPOILERS ahead - for the ones who didn't watch it yet)
In Avengers: Endgame, we learn that Thanos destroys the Infinity Stones. And then, the Avengers go back in time (perhaps to different realities) in order to gather Infinity Stones. Once they finish their work with these Infinity Stones, they are taken back to their respective realities. So, in the main timeline, where they bring back the dusted characters, there are no infinity stones.
But, consider the Time Stone. Doctor Strange and his sanctum swore to protect the Time Stone.
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame
New contributor
(SPOILERS ahead - for the ones who didn't watch it yet)
In Avengers: Endgame, we learn that Thanos destroys the Infinity Stones. And then, the Avengers go back in time (perhaps to different realities) in order to gather Infinity Stones. Once they finish their work with these Infinity Stones, they are taken back to their respective realities. So, in the main timeline, where they bring back the dusted characters, there are no infinity stones.
But, consider the Time Stone. Doctor Strange and his sanctum swore to protect the Time Stone.
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame
New contributor
New contributor
edited 3 hours ago
Ankit Sharma
78.1k65421641
78.1k65421641
New contributor
asked 3 hours ago
Shravan MuraliShravan Murali
111
111
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
Then, why did Doctor Strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
What other choice did he have?
Of the 14,000,605 outcomes there was only one way to win.
Strange had to give up the Time Stone to let the remaining Avengers on Titan continue to live (Thanos would have killed them otherwise) so that ultimate victory could be achieved.
If Tony Stark is killed by Thanos on Titan during Infinity War then he can't be there to complete the victory in Endgame.
Once the final battle is over, Captain America returns the Time Stone to it's proper place in the timeline (with The Ancient One) who will eventually leave it in Kamar-Taj for Doctor Strange to "inherit".
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame?
Remember that Strange had seen 14,000,605 possible futures in Infinity War and was trying to bring about the one scenario where they won.
If Tony dies in Infinity War, he doesn't
solve the time travel navigation problem that they have initially in Endgame.
If someone else fixes that, he's not around to
come up with the idea of jumping back to the 70s to try and regain the Tesseract and more Pym Particles after the trouble they have in 2012.
If someone else thinks of that, he's
not there at the final fight to grab the stones off Thanos and carry out the final snap to destroy both Thanos and his attacking army.
Tony was absolutely key to the single winning scenario. As Dr Strange knew this already, he had to do whatever was necessary to ensure that Tony didn't die in Infinity War.
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Then, why did Doctor Strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
What other choice did he have?
Of the 14,000,605 outcomes there was only one way to win.
Strange had to give up the Time Stone to let the remaining Avengers on Titan continue to live (Thanos would have killed them otherwise) so that ultimate victory could be achieved.
If Tony Stark is killed by Thanos on Titan during Infinity War then he can't be there to complete the victory in Endgame.
Once the final battle is over, Captain America returns the Time Stone to it's proper place in the timeline (with The Ancient One) who will eventually leave it in Kamar-Taj for Doctor Strange to "inherit".
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor Strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
What other choice did he have?
Of the 14,000,605 outcomes there was only one way to win.
Strange had to give up the Time Stone to let the remaining Avengers on Titan continue to live (Thanos would have killed them otherwise) so that ultimate victory could be achieved.
If Tony Stark is killed by Thanos on Titan during Infinity War then he can't be there to complete the victory in Endgame.
Once the final battle is over, Captain America returns the Time Stone to it's proper place in the timeline (with The Ancient One) who will eventually leave it in Kamar-Taj for Doctor Strange to "inherit".
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor Strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
What other choice did he have?
Of the 14,000,605 outcomes there was only one way to win.
Strange had to give up the Time Stone to let the remaining Avengers on Titan continue to live (Thanos would have killed them otherwise) so that ultimate victory could be achieved.
If Tony Stark is killed by Thanos on Titan during Infinity War then he can't be there to complete the victory in Endgame.
Once the final battle is over, Captain America returns the Time Stone to it's proper place in the timeline (with The Ancient One) who will eventually leave it in Kamar-Taj for Doctor Strange to "inherit".
Then, why did Doctor Strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame ?
What other choice did he have?
Of the 14,000,605 outcomes there was only one way to win.
Strange had to give up the Time Stone to let the remaining Avengers on Titan continue to live (Thanos would have killed them otherwise) so that ultimate victory could be achieved.
If Tony Stark is killed by Thanos on Titan during Infinity War then he can't be there to complete the victory in Endgame.
Once the final battle is over, Captain America returns the Time Stone to it's proper place in the timeline (with The Ancient One) who will eventually leave it in Kamar-Taj for Doctor Strange to "inherit".
edited 1 min ago
answered 3 hours ago
Paulie_DPaulie_D
91k18327301
91k18327301
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
add a comment |
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
The Doctor Strange who "inherits" the stone is from a different reality isn't that ? What about the one in the main timeline (2023) ?
– Shravan Murali
2 hours ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
He no longer has a time stone since it was destroyed by Thanos.
– bobbyalex
1 hour ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
The exact possibilities that Dr. Strange had seen is 14,000,605 @paulie_d
– deepak kumar
31 mins ago
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame?
Remember that Strange had seen 14,000,605 possible futures in Infinity War and was trying to bring about the one scenario where they won.
If Tony dies in Infinity War, he doesn't
solve the time travel navigation problem that they have initially in Endgame.
If someone else fixes that, he's not around to
come up with the idea of jumping back to the 70s to try and regain the Tesseract and more Pym Particles after the trouble they have in 2012.
If someone else thinks of that, he's
not there at the final fight to grab the stones off Thanos and carry out the final snap to destroy both Thanos and his attacking army.
Tony was absolutely key to the single winning scenario. As Dr Strange knew this already, he had to do whatever was necessary to ensure that Tony didn't die in Infinity War.
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame?
Remember that Strange had seen 14,000,605 possible futures in Infinity War and was trying to bring about the one scenario where they won.
If Tony dies in Infinity War, he doesn't
solve the time travel navigation problem that they have initially in Endgame.
If someone else fixes that, he's not around to
come up with the idea of jumping back to the 70s to try and regain the Tesseract and more Pym Particles after the trouble they have in 2012.
If someone else thinks of that, he's
not there at the final fight to grab the stones off Thanos and carry out the final snap to destroy both Thanos and his attacking army.
Tony was absolutely key to the single winning scenario. As Dr Strange knew this already, he had to do whatever was necessary to ensure that Tony didn't die in Infinity War.
add a comment |
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame?
Remember that Strange had seen 14,000,605 possible futures in Infinity War and was trying to bring about the one scenario where they won.
If Tony dies in Infinity War, he doesn't
solve the time travel navigation problem that they have initially in Endgame.
If someone else fixes that, he's not around to
come up with the idea of jumping back to the 70s to try and regain the Tesseract and more Pym Particles after the trouble they have in 2012.
If someone else thinks of that, he's
not there at the final fight to grab the stones off Thanos and carry out the final snap to destroy both Thanos and his attacking army.
Tony was absolutely key to the single winning scenario. As Dr Strange knew this already, he had to do whatever was necessary to ensure that Tony didn't die in Infinity War.
Then, why did Doctor strange give away the Time Stone to Thanos while it's anyway not there at the end of Endgame?
Remember that Strange had seen 14,000,605 possible futures in Infinity War and was trying to bring about the one scenario where they won.
If Tony dies in Infinity War, he doesn't
solve the time travel navigation problem that they have initially in Endgame.
If someone else fixes that, he's not around to
come up with the idea of jumping back to the 70s to try and regain the Tesseract and more Pym Particles after the trouble they have in 2012.
If someone else thinks of that, he's
not there at the final fight to grab the stones off Thanos and carry out the final snap to destroy both Thanos and his attacking army.
Tony was absolutely key to the single winning scenario. As Dr Strange knew this already, he had to do whatever was necessary to ensure that Tony didn't die in Infinity War.
answered 29 mins ago
DaveDave
9,62223761
9,62223761
add a comment |
add a comment |